All these different concepts have in common two key underlying foundations
- The first key underlying foundation is the recognition that actors‘ bounded rationality. This means that people have boundaries within which their rational thinking can happen. In this people fundamentally differe from computer information processors and that means that we cannot be fully objective when we process information. We are all limited with our individual cognitive abilities, existing knowledge, or trainings that can help or hinder understanding the incoming information, additionally we tend to have limited time to truly think about huge amounts of information with which we are surrounded at every moment. On top of that, our moods, relationships with people, and past experiences all contribute to how we react to the information.
This results in mental heuristics, which are simplified mental processes that our brains employ to do shortcuts and quickly processes the information, but this includes filtering information in a „biased“ manner conforming to everything we already know. Imagine them like mental shortcuts, our brains often simplify mental processes to make them quicker and more directional, thus saving us time and energy, by not analysing all the information that we have. In very common terms, judging books by its covers is a typical example of mental heuristics.
- Secondly, these theories will claim that all knowledge is socially constructed. Given the role the different cognitions (values, beliefs, worldviews, etc.) have over our conduct and how they frame any incoming information, this necessarily means that any knowledge production is shaped by social processes, culture, history, and power, therefore any knowledge is produced through human interactions, institutions, and contexts. Consequenty, truly objective, neutral knowledge cannot be produced.
Psychological Barriers to Consensus: Bayesian Updating, Framing, and Conflicting Narratives in Marine Protection Policies
This is, psychologically speaking, an unescapable result of how people think. There is a process called Bayesian updating, which describes the process of attaching new knowledge to existing beliefs. This simply means that we revise what we believe based on new information that we receive, but that new information has to conform with our existing belief or it gets adapted to it.
Similarly, the frame theory, which claims that as we grow up, our values, beliefs, norms, and experiences form frames in our minds and all incoming information gets filtered through those frames. If the information is aligned with our existing frames we easily integrate it. If it conflicts with them, we tend to find reasons to reject it or simply ignore it. For example, think of the bear story case, that you have just encountered. If your frame is conservationist, where bears have a right to be in the forest and you are convinced people exert too much of an influence over nature already, the incoming information will be filtered through your frame and let you arrive at a different conclusion, then if you are someone who might have already lived through a traumatic experience with a bear and would rather see their numbers significantly reduced.
Both of these processes contribute to the so-called confirmation bias, where we attach greater weight to the evidence that supports what we already believe and build bubbles and subcultures. If you are already convinced that biodiversity crisis is dire and we are not doing enough to address it, every new piece of information supporting that conviction will be more easily and readily seen as valid, while pieces of information that would support behaviours and actions that go against that would be scrutinised more or rejected out of hand.
So how does this translate into a case study of biodiversity science-policy-society interfaces? A study has tried to delve into understandings of social constructions amongst key policy actors and experts on the topic of strict protection of marine ecosystems and how they influence their prioritisation amongst EU policies. Among the same types of key actors, when they are trying to use EU policies to provide strict or effective protection of marine nature, there are at least 5 distinct framings in place. They can be subsumed into two overarching ones, one arguing for more environmental protection, which covers the left 4 categories and the Sustainable use of marine resources one on the other hand (Gorjanc et al.,2024: https://doi.org/10.1111/csp2.13199).
Types of framing
Very strong framing
Very Strong framing would claim that we are facing a massive crisis and we need to do everything possible to avert it. That would include protecting 30% of EU seas as no-take areas, 10% as no-go areas, we should also prohibit bottom-trawling in all EU seas and focus on hard enforcement of existing policies.
Strict Framing
Strict framing agrees that the crisis is dire and also wants full implementation of conservation policies, only slightly more pragmatic about it. 30% multiple use protected areas, 10% no-take areas, no general bans and maritime spatial planning approach in unprotected parts of the seas.
Regional Framing
Regional framing is the only one that would prefer more soft law approaches and more action to be catalysed through Regional Sea Conventions rather than the EU. Still they are in favour of pursuing functional protection and are committed to more science and 30:10 protection targets in principle.
Pragmatic framing
Pragmatic framing is the most optimistic of them, claiming that we have everything we need in place, we just need to close the implementation gap now and that is doable in the current decade. While supportive of conservation actions, they would prefer to focus on the rest of environmental policies, as without reducing pressures overall, MPAs are of limited use. So the approach to protection would be more flexible and adaptable, case-by-case.
Sustainable use framing
Finally, Sustainable Use framing, centres people and their needs first. They claim that sustainable uses of seas are possible, while not what is currently happening. Still they would mainly work through Maritime Spatial Planning and Common Fisheries Policy. They dont oppose conservation targets per se, but would like them applied on a case-by-case basis.
Each of these framings is based on some scientific literature, at least some EU policy committments, and actors‘ worldviews and convictions. The framings are thus unlikely to easily change and they have a role in interpretation of data, with actors often using the same dataset, but using the results to support actions in Very Strong approach or the Sustainable Use one. Regardless of the information coming in and having the exact same policies within the EU policy framework for all of these different positions, they can lead to very different choices that we make in the environment itself. So, which policies do we implement and how?