The first module focussed on how different actors in science-policy-society interfaces (SPSIs) perceive each other and how that can influence the functioning of these interfaces. But it is time now to dive deeper into the psychological theories and illustrate how they play out in the biodiversity SPSIs.
As we already learnt, most predominant preconception of how science-policy-society interfaces work are fairly linear and those conceptions do have some basis in different psychological theories. Let's have a look at a few of them!
Theory of Reasoned Action
Theory of Reasoned Action assumes that people base their behaviour based on what they consider desired and intended behaviour, which is informed by knowledge and information that we take on board and which also shapes our beliefs and values. Therefore, the theory assumes a conscious and information-based decision making chain. That means that each individual's behaviours, values, and beliefs are informed by incoming and rational information.
If you are working in a decision-making institution or a policy institution and you get new information about potential positive impacts of extensification of agriculture on grassland biodiversity. Before deciding on what you will do with this new information and how you will integrate into your policy decisions, you're probably going to consider the position of your institution in this. If you're more on the conservation side, your decision will probably go more towards supporting extensification because the data exist that supports such a course. If you're more on the agricultural side, you might want to have more data on the impacts on agriculture before considering making a decision. The incoming information is the same, but the final decision is depended on expected behaviour that one should show in their particular position.
Homo economics
The Homo economics model is based on rational weighting of different choices that we face, aiming to maximise personal gain, profit, and short-term benefits. This is still a rational balancing act that happens consciously, wherein people naturally prioritise »selfish« outcomes that are tangible and quickly achievable.
While there exist many other theories explaining in detail how human rational decision-making processes work (see some papers in the Literature), it is fair to say that if we assume that human decision-making is based on rationality (incoming information is dictating what decisions should be made), this
leads to certain ways in which SPSIs should also
work.
The Homo economics model can therefore explain how many of the political level decisions are being made, where the elected officials' positions are dependent on the short electoral cycles. Therefore, they will more likely make decisions and support policies which will be quickly favoured by the public and could bring concrete benefits during their tenure. Among the policy actor levels (i.e. civil/career servants), this model could explain behaviour where easy fixes and quick solutions are prioritised, to allow the policy cycles to move on, while the impression of efficiency can result in better career opportunities, even though the policy actors can be well aware that the solutions they have implemented are not sustainable in the longer term.
Rule of experts
Rule of experts presupposes that since our policy decisions should be based on sound evidence and data driven, and if we assume that knowledge drives decision making, then we are ruled by experts who are providing the knowledge, as they hold significant power over decision-making, potentially at the expense of democratic or political participation, where expert knowledge becomes the main source of authority.
In reality, this is often more of a wish for the science part of the SPSIs, but there are cases where simply provision of data or expertise can mean that the space for discussions gets limited. A clear example was the COVID-19 pandemic, where policy decisions in many countries followed the advice of experts, with little to no opportunity for those to be challenged either politically or in the public sphere. In that case, it could be argued that the decisions governing the economic and personal lives of millions were almsot entirely dependent on experts. Within the biodiversity field, such extreme examples are rarer, but there are still cases where simply finding a species or a particular habitat type and mapping them can create a requirement for the country to designate protected areas (such as Natura 2000 areas in Europe) and impose regimes within them. While the boundaries of such designations and the specifics of the conservation regimes can and should be more widely discussed, the baseline expertise already narrowed the scope for democratic and political participation.
Scientifically sanctioned rationality
Scientifically sanctioned rationality favours scientific data over other forms of knowledge to the point that it can be seen excluding other voices and knowledges. Science thus determines what can be the rational range of discussion, as anything contradicting scientific knowledge is seen a without value.
This can be observed in cases of human-wildlife conflict management with large carnivores, for example. Often the management strategies for large carnivores are based on scientific and monitoring data, which are the bases for determining population sizes, genetic health of populations, environmental carrying capacity, etc. Based on these scientific data, mitigation strategies, potential culls, compensations and other measures are being designed. However, compared to scientific data in this case, the eyewitness accounts or stories told by stakeholder groups or local populations are often given a lower influence over the decisions that are ultimately taken, because they can be perceived as subjective, exaggerated, or unreliable compared to statistical models.
Such conceptions (both theories and the resulting role of experts and science) support the linear conception of the science-policy-society interfaces, as they focus on the information that is used for people to make their decisions. Therefore, if we only provide the right information, that should inform both policy decisions and societal attitudes.
Out of the following options, what do you think holds the greatest sway over people's decision making? There is no right answer!
Behaviours
Attitudes
Perceptions
Beliefs
Values
Evidence