Group dynamics are important as working in groups is key for much of scientific and policy work and thus introduce even more complexities as group dynamics further influence information processing and interpretation, as well as directly influences implementation of decisions taken.
The key challenge that everyone should be aware of is that due to often poor understandings of the way in which personally held constructions differ, misunderstandings can arise, which are not necessarily recognised, leading to the phenomenon of „multiple ignorances“. This occurs when we seemingly reach consensus, but we still deep down disagree on key tenets of that consensual decision and subsequently sabotage the success of the implementation of the decision taken by acting on those differing underlying tenets of the decision. Alternative results can be that the group members only comply with the decision in the moment, to then distance themselves during the implementation phase. A clear example of that are how EU environmental policies are made. The legislative process requires a high level of consensus before any policy can be passed, but it is easily observed how differently different Member States then implement those same policies.
The alternative and the desired outcome would be to reach cognitive consensus, which is a consensus were all group members are aligned in what they decide, on the underlying tenets, and the ways of implementing the consensus. It is a challenging task to try and achieve that, difficult without acknowledgement of different positions, framing, value systems, power dynamics, and in the absence of proper moderation and facilitation to drive the group process.
The cognitions and constructions which were mentioned earlier can interfere with the ability to cognitively view the same topic in a similar way. Therefore, the processes to reach group interpretation and actual cognitive consensus are challenging to achieve, particularly as long as we operate under the conception that people process and compare information in a similar, rational, and dispassionate way and thus move through the group interactions relying mainly on provision of facts, proofs, with which we are trying to convince the others.
In order to illustrate this on a concrete example, linked to the one above, a recent study conducted workshops with policy actors and experts on the topic of marine strict protection to see to what extent people change their opinions and positions in discussions with others, and to see if group dynamics drive the process towards consensus (Gorjanc, 2023: https://doi.org/10.55268/CM.2023.53.122). Participants were presented with 5 controversial statements and asked to take a position about how much they agree or disagree with them. Then they debated their positions, providing arguments and rationales for why they are at certain positions. On the slide you can see the results for the Mediterranean sea, but the results from the Black sea, as well as the North and Baltic seas were very similar. The results show that a modest number of participants changed opinions after the exchange, about 15% in general, and mostly due to initial misunderstandings of statements. This indicates that simply the provision of data and arguments, even among trusted experts has limited influence on the positions that these key actors assume and maintain, therefore also having an impact on how they implement policies, as their decisions are not just founded on the evidence they are given and that they engage with, but on a number of other socio-psychological elements, which have so far not really been engaged with.