While previous modules explored how individuals think and how group dynamics function, this module addresses a critical, often unspoken layer of interaction: power.
In biodiversity conservation and environmental management, participatory approaches are increasingly used, sometimes becoming a "tick-box" exercise. However, simply gathering people does not guarantee equitable outcomes.
As noted by researcher Lou Lecuyer :
While literature frequently states that "power is important," it often stops there without explaining how to navigate it.
Power is not merely a negative force of coercion; it is fluid, dynamic, and present in every interaction. It shapes our daily lives, decisions, and the success of participatory processes. Understanding power is essential to moving from a simple transfer of knowledge to genuine transformation and justice.
In this module you will discover:
- The PowerBiodiv project
- The 3 aspects of power
- How power is everywhere
- The Multidimensional Framework of Power
- The arenas of power
- The expressions of power
- The spaces and levels of power
- What evidence says
- How to work with power
- How to navigate the assymetries
- Questions for self reflection
The Powerbiodiv project
Understanding power dynamics in stakeholder participation: integrating theory and practice for effective biodiversity conservation
The complex nature of biodiversity conservation has led to increased stakeholder engagement through participatory processes, but often without a clear understanding of how or if they lead to stronger or more sustainable biodiversity outcomes. Recent studies highlight the urgent need for a more comprehensive understanding of the multiple dimensions of power that pervade such processes, and how this understanding can lead to improved processes and biodiversity conservation.
Based on a transdisciplinary approach, PowerBioDiv addresses the existing gap in understanding linkages between power dynamics and improved stakeholder participation processes in biodiversity conservation. It asks:
- How can a multidimensional power analysis allow us to better understand the context, design, as well as social and biodiversity outcomes of stakeholder participation processes?
- What strategies in theory and practice exist to overcome the challenges related to power dynamics?
- What role can and should researchers, institutional representatives, and practitioners play in the design and implementation of stakeholder participation processes that address power dynamics?
PowerBioDiv adopts an “evidence informed” approach that includes scientific and grey literatures, but also other expert knowledge and sources of validated evidence. To do so, PowerBioDiv uses well recognised methodologies for knowledge synthesis including high quality systematic reviews to integrate social and political theories of power in the conservation literature, with solution scanning and expert consultation to access the perspectives, stories, and knowledges not typically represented in conservation literature. PowerBioDiv benefits both science and practice by providing a practical approach to addressing and integrating power dynamics in stakeholder processes with the aim of improving sustainable biodiversity conservation.
Understanding power dynamics
The PowerBioDiv project explored the 3 big aspects of power:
- Understanding power: Framework and codebook
- Observing power
- Systematic review
Before we dive deeper into this content, we would like to ask you:
What is power to you?
Before diving into theory, take a moment to reflect. What are three words you associate with "power"?
Answer reveal
There is no right answer here. It is encouraging to see power viewed positively (e.g., "freedom," "agency"). However, we must recognise that power is complex and context-dependent.
Some of the answers we had so far: Clarity, Agency, influence, leverage, persuasion, strenght, empathy, competence, sustainability, capacity, strengh, framework, influence, confidence, agency, Influence, Hidden, Strength, responsibility, leverage, influence, strength, influence, listening influence, action, achievement, convince, activate, confidence, strength, manipulation, influence, oppression, achieve.