The other thing that has to be realised is that the policy world itself is incredibly complex. In the EU, there are more than 300 policies related to the marine environment, together including above 12.000 regulations. Each of these policies comes with a process, steps which need to be followed, milestones to be achieved, reports submitted, etc. And often the same public servant deals with numerous policies at the same time, which makes them busy and trying to balance multiple things at the same time. Sadly, that often means they are doing their best to keep numerous fires under control, while being spread too thin to completely put them out.
This is important to realise when trying to reach them, give them information, and have them act on it.
Therefore, it is important to realise that pure scientific knowledge rarely directly influences policy making, with more focus on state assessments, which tend to be based on long-term national monitoring programmes. But importantly, it is also crucial to realise that since policy actors often come from research, they are acutely aware of how research field functions, the dependency on funding, and on emphasising uncertainty, the differences between competing papers or institutions, etc. They look for specific experts or institutions to produce directly the policy relevant knowledge that they need to implement their policies. Therefore, the functioning of science policy interfaces isn’t linear from knowledge to policy, but policy directly influences the knowledge that is being produced.
Also very important is to realise that often policy makers get information from their own networks, which means that beyond data provision, there are issues of trust, personal relationships, agency, power, group dynamics, and more that influence which knowledge is accepted, retained, or acted upon.
Question 4
What is the main source of information for a policy maker?
Explore potential answers below.
Scientific papers
While sometimes they are read among the policy actors, it is generally safe to assume they won't be read. It is difficult to find the time to read briefs, abstracts, and executive summaries often, therefore, whole papers rarely get read.
Political guidelines
Political realities shape what can and can't be done in the policy world, but the actual political guidelines might not be as important as one would imagine. While care must be taken to present new policies in a way that can gather political support, much of policy work goes on along its cycles on which the current political guidelines have less direct impact.
State/regional monitoring and assessments
This is often where most information for policy comes from. Partly because it is directly paid and designed for the specific policy and reporting needs and partly because it tends to build on long-term datasets and systematic monitoring
Their own network of experts
Often years long interactions between policy actors and experts do turn into networks where much of information for policy making and checking of new information happens.
Own research/background
It can have a profound influence, although there will need to be new and more evidence collected for foundations of policy decisions, but own backgrounds can direct what kind of evidence is sougth and how it is interpreted.
Media
Media tends to be used more to get information on what is happening in society and which topics are relevant there, whereas it is not commonly used for evidence base for policies.
Answer reveal
There are no right or wrong answers here; this quiz is designed to encourage you to reflect on your own perspective regarding the subject.